Tonight, I hope City Council will reconsider the plan for 10 acres at Evans Plaza to be redesignated Lowrise 1 Mixed Use from General Commercial, as was recommended by the Planning Commission. The proposal has already received significant pushback from the community, who wrote letters and appeared at the Planning Commission hearing in opposition. There is also a June 9th letter written on behalf of the applicant that expresses limited enthusiasm for the land use change (page 7) if they’re only allowed building heights of 60 feet (though tonight’s presentation says this could be 60 feet + potential bonus).
Only three Planning Commissioners (Lu, Ferris, and Nilchian) out of seven voted for this land use redesignation (which will support a rezoning application), since two were absent (Villaveces and Khanloo). It was also a particularly busy night for the Planning Commission, which held three public hearings in one night, limiting the time for discussion of each.

It violates my sense of fairness and rule of law to authorize a major change like this only two years since the land use map was last redefined as part of the Comprehensive Plan update in 2024. Spot upzones are not supposed to occur; when we respond to changing community needs, we look at the whole city to see what other parcels should be updated at the same time.
The city does have a process for determining whether a land use change like this is appropriate, and the first major question is whether the requirement of Significantly Changed Conditions has been met. Nothing has physically changed in the area around Evans Plaza. Staff is treating the updated plan text, with its intent to add housing, as a change that indicates that this is a redesignation consistent with city policies, but I think this is quite a stretch (page 33 of Staff Report, or page 13 of the 7/22 minutes). Another contested piece is the question of whether this is an existing neighborhood center, which was a surprise to nearby residents.
One of the most problematic outcomes I’m concerned about is the fact that approving this land use change, and later, upzone would create legitimately “significantly changed conditions” for the Dunn Lumber parcel across the street. This is a regional supplier that seems kinda important for our goal of facilitating housing production. How much farther will construction workers need to travel for these supplies if this source is lost? This would be inefficient and in opposition to our climate goals.
(more…)